25+ Stunning Baby Shower Cookies That Will Wow Your Guests

Planning a baby shower and looking for the perfect sweet treats? Custom decorated cookies have become one of the hottest trends for baby celebrations, and for good reason – they’re beautiful, delicious, and double as memorable keepsakes.

Whether you’re throwing a boho-chic shower, a whimsical woodland party, or a classic pink-and-blue celebration, the right cookie designs can tie your entire theme together and leave guests talking about your event for months.

In this guide, I’m sharing 25+ absolutely gorgeous baby shower cookie ideas that range from elegant and sophisticated to playful and fun. Let’s explore the sweetest cookie inspiration for your upcoming celebration!

Why Choose Custom Cookies for Your Baby Shower?

Before we dive into the designs, let’s talk about why baby shower cookies have become so popular:

Visual Impact: Beautifully decorated cookies create an Instagram-worthy dessert table that guests will love photographing and sharing.

Theme Coordination: Custom cookies can match any baby shower theme, color scheme, or design aesthetic perfectly.

Versatile Favors: Cookies work wonderfully as both dessert and party favors, eliminating the need for separate thank-you gifts.

Personal Touch: Adding the baby’s name, due date, or special messages makes cookies feel extra meaningful and personalized.

1. Vintage Baby Carriage Cookie Collection

Transport guests back in time with this charming vintage-inspired set featuring delicate baby carriages, floating balloon clusters, and adorable teddy bear accents.

The real showstopper? Beautiful ombré name plaques with gradient frosting that transitions seamlessly from one soft shade to another. The tiny teddy bear detail on the onesie cookie adds an extra touch of sweetness that’s almost too cute to eat.

Perfect for: Classic baby showers, “We Can Bearly Wait” themes, traditional baby boy celebrations

Color palette: Muted blues, soft grays, cream

2. Celestial Moon and Stars Cookie Set

Reach for the stars with this dreamy celestial collection that’s been wildly popular in recent years.

Featuring a gorgeous combination of muted baby blue, warm taupe, and shimmering gold accents, these cookies capture that magical “over the moon” feeling. The standout piece is a crescent moon cookie adorned with a dimensional balloon garland design – a trendy element that adds depth and visual interest.

Baby rattles decorated with tiny stars complete this heavenly set.

Perfect for: “Love You to the Moon and Back” themes, gender-neutral showers, evening celebrations

Color palette: Baby blue, taupe, metallic gold

3. Retro Daisy Baby Shower Cookies

Bring some flower power to your baby shower with this groovy 70s-inspired cookie collection!

Featuring cheerful daisies in dusty rose and pastel pink shades, these cookies tap into the nostalgic bohemian aesthetic that’s been making a major comeback. The playful lettered cookies spell out “BABY” with each letter decorated in complementary floral patterns.

Perfect for: Retro-themed showers, spring baby celebrations, flower garden themes

Color palette: Dusty rose, pastel pink, cream, sage green

4. “Reel Excited” Fishing Themed Cookies

For the outdoor-loving family, this fishing-themed set is an absolute catch!

This unique collection includes artistic fish plaques with watercolor effects, vintage-style bobbers, realistic fishing lures, and the cutest onesie decorated with a fish scale pattern. The “We’re reel excited” baby announcement plaque ties everything together with a clever pun that guests will love.

Perfect for: Outdoor enthusiasts, lake house showers, dad-focused “Daddy’s Little Catch” themes

Color palette: Navy blue, forest green, orange, natural wood tones

5. Teddy Bear “We Can Bearly Wait” Collection

Sometimes the classic teddy bear theme is exactly what you need, and this set proves why it never goes out of style.

Featuring adorable teddy bears in various poses, these cookies showcase impressive hand-piped calligraphy that personalizes each piece with the baby’s name. The detail work on the bears – from their fuzzy texture to their sweet expressions – demonstrates true cookie artistry.

Perfect for: Traditional baby showers, teddy bear picnic themes, woodland nursery themes

Color palette: Warm browns, cream, soft pastels

6. Minimalist Watercolor Cookie Set

Working with a tighter budget but still want custom cookies? This simplified approach proves that less can definitely be more.

By focusing on just one or two cohesive designs rather than an elaborate multi-piece set, you can achieve a stunning look without breaking the bank. These mint green watercolor cookies feature soft brush strokes and elegant simplicity that feels modern and fresh.

Perfect for: Minimalist celebrations, modern baby showers, budget-conscious hosts

Color palette: Mint green, white, soft gray

7. Boho Baby Blocks and Rattan Crib Set

Channel those natural, earthy vibes with this beautiful boho collection that feels light, airy, and perfectly on-trend.

Featuring realistic wooden baby blocks with embossed letters, a detailed rattan crib complete with texture, boho baby bottles, and artistic line drawings of expectant mothers, this set captures the free-spirited bohemian aesthetic that so many modern mamas love.

Perfect for: Boho baby showers, natural/organic themes, gender-neutral celebrations

Color palette: Nude, taupe, sage green, terracotta

8. Safari Animals Jungle Cookie Collection

Who says baby shower cookies can’t be wild? This contemporary jungle safari set brings the animal kingdom to your dessert table in the most stylish way.

Featuring adorable lions, giraffes, elephants, and zebras rendered in modern, whimsical styles, these cookies skip the traditional primary colors in favor of sophisticated muted tones. Palm leaves and tropical foliage add that authentic safari atmosphere.

Perfect for: Jungle/safari themes, zoo-themed showers, animal-loving families

Color palette: Sage green, mustard yellow, terracotta, cream

9. Embossed Onesie and Crib Set

For a textured, dimensional look, cookie stamps and fondant create this pretty embossed effect that stands out from typical flat decorated cookies.

The delicate pink and white onesies feature intricate patterns pressed into the fondant, while the coordinating crib cookies showcase fine detail work that looks almost three-dimensional. It’s a sophisticated take on classic baby shower imagery.

Perfect for: Elegant baby showers, traditional pink celebrations, vintage-inspired events

Color palette: Soft pink, crisp white, pearl accents

10. Frilly Baby Mobile Cookie Collection

This ultra-feminine set features gorgeous gradient ombré baby mobiles, ruffled-sleeve onesies, and an ornate baby bassinet that looks like it belongs in a fairytale nursery.

The attention to detail is incredible – the bassinet even includes a tiny initialed baby blanket. One adorable addition? A cookie shaped like the family’s beloved pet, patiently waiting for baby’s arrival. It’s these personal touches that make custom cookies so special.

Perfect for: Princess-themed showers, elegant baby girl celebrations, pink and gold themes

Color palette: Blush pink, white, rose gold

11. Earthy Boho Rainbow and Rattle Set

Embrace those warm, natural tones with this earthy collection featuring knotted baby gowns, modern rattles, and beautiful boho arches.

The arches are personalized with both mama and baby’s names, creating a special connection between mother and child. The muted apricot, nude, and green color scheme feels organic and calming – perfect for a zen, nature-inspired celebration.

Perfect for: Boho showers, neutral gender celebrations, earth mama themes

Color palette: Nude, apricot, sage green, cream

12. “Sweet As A Peach” Watercolor Cookies

These peachy-keen cookies are as sweet as the theme suggests!

Featuring delicate watercolor peach illustrations and matching peach-painted onesies, this set brings a fresh fruity twist to baby shower desserts. The soft watercolor technique creates a gentle, artistic look that feels hand-painted and special.

Perfect for: Summer baby showers, Georgia-themed celebrations, sweet fruit themes

Color palette: Peach, coral, soft pink, mint green

13. Forest Green and Yellow Boho Boy Set

Who says boho has to be all neutral? This warm and vibrant set proves that earthy can also mean colorful!

Deep forest green paired with sunny golden yellow creates a cozy, nature-inspired palette that feels both masculine and welcoming. The most impressive detail? Cookie scenes that transform simple oval shapes into darling nursery vignettes showing onesies and swaddles hanging on a clothesline. It’s cookie artistry at its finest.

Perfect for: Boho baby boy showers, outdoor themes, autumn celebrations

Color palette: Forest green, deep yellow, cream, wood tones

14. Neutral Caramel Boho Cookie Set

For those who love the barely-there beauty of neutral palettes, this creamy caramel collection is absolute perfection.

Featuring trendy palm fronds, rainbow teething toys, and even a silhouette cookie of the mama-to-be showing off her beautiful bump, this set celebrates both baby and mother. The monochromatic color story feels sophisticated and modern.

Perfect for: Minimalist boho showers, neutral nursery themes, modern celebrations

Color palette: Caramel, cream, nude, soft tan

15. “A Little Cutie” Orange and Arch Set

Citrus lovers, this one’s for you! This minimalist “Little Cutie” collection features architectural arch cookies in varying sizes, an adorable romper, and a beautifully detailed woven crib.

The textured swaddle blanket in the crib adds realistic dimension, while the clean lines and simple color palette keep everything feeling fresh and contemporary. The orange and neutral combination is unexpected and totally gorgeous.

Perfect for: Citrus themes, modern minimalist showers, summer celebrations

Color palette: Burnt orange, cream, sage green

16. Baby Lion and Pampas Grass Set

Lions and lambs and pampas grass, oh my!

This nature-inspired neutral set features the sweetest whimsical baby lion, elegant initial rattles, botanical greenery, and trendy pampas grass accents. The nude and green color scheme feels organic and peaceful, while the lion adds just the right amount of playful personality.

Perfect for: Safari themes, boho celebrations, neutral gender showers

Color palette: Nude, sage green, cream, soft gray

17. Blue Marble and Gold Geometric Set

For a modern, luxurious look, marble and metallic accents create show-stopping results.

This sophisticated collection features cookies decorated with blue marble fondant patterns paired with geometric shapes in shimmering gold. Baby blocks, bottles, and onesies get the high-end treatment with this elegant design approach that feels more upscale boutique than traditional baby shower.

Perfect for: Upscale showers, modern geometric themes, luxury celebrations

Color palette: Navy blue, white marble, metallic gold

18. Rainbow Baby Celebration Cookies

Celebrate your precious rainbow baby with a joyful collection that honors the journey.

Featuring beautiful rainbow designs in soft, muted tones rather than bright primary colors, these cookies incorporate clouds, rain drops, and sunshine elements that tell a story of hope and new beginnings. It’s a touching way to acknowledge the special significance of this baby’s arrival.

Perfect for: Rainbow baby showers, hope and promise themes, meaningful celebrations

Color palette: Soft rainbow pastels, white, silver

19. Hot Air Balloon Adventure Set

Take your guests on an adventure with this whimsical hot air balloon collection!

Featuring detailed balloon cookies with intricate basket weaving patterns, fluffy clouds, and “adventure awaits” banner cookies, this set captures the excitement of new beginnings and the journey ahead. The dimensional elements make these cookies look like they’re actually floating.

Perfect for: Travel-themed showers, adventure awaits themes, nursery decor-inspired events

Color palette: Dusty blue, blush pink, cream, gold

20. Butterfly Garden Cookie Collection

Flutter into spring with this delicate butterfly and floral garden set.

Featuring realistic monarch and swallowtail butterflies, blooming flowers, and nature-inspired elements, these cookies bring the beauty of a garden party indoors. The detailed wing patterns on the butterflies showcase incredible piping skills and artistic vision.

Perfect for: Spring showers, garden party themes, butterfly nursery themes

Color palette: Soft pink, lavender, mint green, yellow

21. Woodland Creatures and Forest Set

Take a walk through the enchanted forest with this charming woodland creature collection.

Featuring friendly foxes, wise owls, cuddly bears, and tall pine trees, this set creates a complete forest scene across your dessert table. Mushrooms, acorns, and forest foliage complete the woodland wonderland. The muted, natural color palette keeps everything feeling sophisticated rather than overly cutesy.

Perfect for: Woodland themes, camping-inspired showers, nature-loving families

Color palette: Rust orange, forest green, brown, cream

22. Nautical Anchor and Sailboat Set

Ahoy, baby! Set sail with this classic nautical collection.

Crisp navy and white stripes combine with anchor motifs, sailboat cookies, and rope border details to create a timeless maritime look. Life preserver and lighthouse cookies add variety to the set, while personalized name banners can be designed to look like ship flags.

Perfect for: Nautical themes, summer showers, coastal celebrations

Color palette: Navy blue, white, red, gold

23. Llama and Cactus Fiesta Set

No prob-llama – this fiesta-inspired set brings the fun!

Adorable llamas decorated with colorful saddle blankets pair perfectly with potted cacti, sombreros, and “Let’s Fiesta” banner cookies. The playful southwestern vibe is perfect for a celebration with personality and spice. Bright, happy colors make this set feel festive and joyful.

Perfect for: Fiesta themes, southwestern celebrations, llama-loving families

Color palette: Turquoise, coral, yellow, pink, green

24. Elegant Lace and Pearls Set

For the most sophisticated celebration, this elegant lace-inspired collection is pure luxury.

Featuring intricate hand-piped lace patterns that look like delicate embroidery, pearl accents, and classic baby elements elevated with refined details, these cookies would be at home at the fanciest baby shower. Soft colors and vintage-inspired designs create an heirloom quality.

Perfect for: Formal showers, tea party themes, vintage elegant celebrations

Color palette: White, ivory, champagne, soft pink

25. Under the Sea Mermaid Set

Make a splash with this magical under-the-sea mermaid collection!

Featuring shimmering mermaid tails with scaled texture, seashells, starfish, and “Merbaby” wordplay, this set is perfect for parents dreaming of ocean adventures. Waves decorated with royal icing create movement and dimension, while pearls and iridescent accents add that magical underwater sparkle.

Perfect for: Mermaid themes, beach baby showers, ocean-inspired nurseries

Color palette: Aqua, purple, pink, gold, iridescent

26. Twinkle Twinkle Little Star Cookie Set

End the night with stars in your eyes thanks to this dreamy celestial collection.

Golden stars in various sizes pair with crescent moons, cloud cookies, and “Twinkle Twinkle Little Star” lyric plaques to create a sleepy, peaceful atmosphere. Perfect for a nursery rhyme theme, the soft yellows and whites feel gentle and soothing.

Perfect for: Twinkle Twinkle themes, nighttime/lullaby themes, star nurseries

Color palette: Soft yellow, white, silver, pale blue

How to Order Custom Baby Shower Cookies

Ready to order your own stunning cookie set? Here’s what you need to know:

Timeline: Order at least 4-6 weeks in advance for custom designs. Popular cookie artists book up quickly, especially during peak baby season (spring and summer).

Budget: Expect to pay $3-8 per decorated cookie depending on complexity, size, and your location. Complete sets typically range from $50-200.

Quantity: Plan for 1-2 cookies per guest, plus extras for photos and the guest of honor to keep.

Details to Provide: Share your color scheme, theme, inspiration photos, baby’s name (if known), and any specific design elements you’d like included.

Dietary Needs: Ask about options for guests with allergies. Many cookie artists offer gluten-free, nut-free, or vegan alternatives.

Tips for Displaying Baby Shower Cookies

Make your beautiful cookies the star of the show with these display ideas:

• Use a tiered cake stand to create height and visual interest
• Arrange cookies in clear cellophane bags tied with ribbons as grab-and-go favors
• Create a cookie “wall” using a pegboard or grid backdrop
• Display cookies on elegant platters mixed with fresh flowers
• Use small easels to prop up larger statement cookies
• Coordinate your display with the overall baby shower color scheme and decorations

Final Thoughts

Custom baby shower cookies have evolved from simple treats into true works of edible art that can elevate any celebration. Whether you choose elegant and classic designs or bold and whimsical themes, the right cookies will delight your guests and create lasting memories.

The best part? These gorgeous cookies taste as amazing as they look, and they double as party favors that guests will actually appreciate (no dusty knick-knacks here!).

Which cookie design inspired you most? Remember, you can always mix and match elements from different sets to create something completely unique for your celebration. Work with a talented cookie artist to bring your vision to life, and get ready to hear endless compliments at your baby shower!